Close this search box.

Toilet Runs Intermittently: Quick Fixes and Prevention Tips

Toilets are essential fixtures in every home, but they can occasionally develop issues that require attention and maintenance. One common problem faced by homeowners is a toilet that intermittently runs, causing unnecessary water usage and increased utility bills. Understanding why this happens and how to address it can help you maintain your toilet and prevent further problems in the future.

There are numerous factors that can contribute to the intermittent operation of a toilet. From internal leaks to malfunctioning components, the reason behind the issue can vary significantly. Knowing the anatomy of your toilet and recognizing the common signs of a running toilet will guide you through the troubleshooting process and enable you to pinpoint the root cause. With this knowledge, you can determine whether a DIY fix is possible or if it’s time to call a professional plumber for help.

Best Toilet Fill Valves Available Today

Key Takeaways

  • Intermittent toilet running can be caused by various factors, including leaks and malfunctioning parts.
  • Familiarizing yourself with the toilet’s anatomy and recognizing common signs is crucial for troubleshooting.
  • Identifying the cause of the issue can help you decide whether to fix it yourself or consult a professional plumber.

Understanding Why a Toilet Runs Intermittently

About Intermittent Running Toilet

Note: This post may contain affiliate links. This means that at no cost to you, we may receive a small commission for made purchases.

An intermittent running toilet is a common issue where the toilet fills with water and then drains without being flushed. This can be annoying and also waste a significant amount of water over time. There are several reasons for a toilet to run intermittently, and understanding the potential causes can help you to address the issue effectively.

Phantom Flush Phenomenon

One of the most common causes of a toilet running intermittently is the “phantom flush” phenomenon. This occurs when water slowly leaks from the tank into the bowl, causing the toilet to refill periodically without an actual flush. This usually results from a faulty flapper or a worn-out seal on the flush valve. A simple fix for this issue is to replace the flapper or the entire flush valve assembly, ensuring that the water stays in the tank until the toilet is flushed.

Best Toilet Fill Valves Available Today

Faulty Components: A Leading Cause

Several faulty components within the toilet can contribute to intermittent running. One such component is the fill valve. If debris gets caught inside the fill valve or its seal gets worn out, it can cause the toilet to run randomly due to fluctuations in water pressure source. Another area of concern is the water level in the tank. If the water level is too high or too low, it can trigger the toilet to run intermittently source. In these cases, adjusting the water level in the tank or replacing the faulty fill valve can help to resolve the issue.

When addressing an intermittently running toilet, it’s essential to diagnose the problem accurately and take the appropriate steps to fix it. Ensuring a properly functioning toilet not only saves water but also provides peace of mind knowing that your bathroom is working as it should.

Anatomy of a Toilet

The Toilet Tank

The toilet tank is the upper part of the toilet that holds the water used for flushing. Inside the tank, you will find several important components that ensure the proper functioning of the toilet. The fill valve controls the water flow into the tank and is connected to a water supply line. The overflow tube helps to manage excess water in the tank, preventing spills onto the floor.

The flapper is a crucial part responsible for releasing water from the tank into the toilet bowl during a flush. It is connected to the handle by a chain, which lifts the flapper when activated. The fill tube refills the bowl with water after a flush, while the float ball and float arm work in tandem to maintain the water level in the tank. A flush valve controls the flow of water from the tank to the bowl, and a float cup keeps the float from sinking or rising too high.

The Toilet Bowl

The toilet bowl is the lower portion of the toilet that receives the waste after you use the toilet. It is designed to hold and transport waste through a drainpipe connected to the sewer or septic system. The bowl features a trapway, which is a curved internal passage that creates a seal of water, preventing sewer gases from entering your bathroom.

During a flush, water from the toilet tank flows into the bowl, creating a siphon effect that pulls the waste through the trapway and into the drainpipe. This process simultaneously pushes any remaining water down the drain and refills the bowl with clean water from the fill tube. The toilet bowl is an essential component of a properly functioning toilet, working together with the various parts inside the toilet tank to ensure a clean, efficient, and odor-free experience.

Common Signs of a Running Toilet

A running toilet is not only an annoyance but can also lead to higher water bills and potential plumbing problems. This section focuses on the signs of a running toilet and how to identify the underlying issues.

How to Spot a Leaky Toilet

A leaky toilet is often a primary cause of a toilet running intermittently. Some common indicators of a leaky toilet include the sound of water trickling into the bowl or a toilet that spontaneously refills as though someone flushed it. This condition is referred to as a “phantom flush”. The primary cause of a phantom flush is a slow leak from the tank into the bowl, which might require a flapper replacement or an adjustment to the fill valve.

To determine whether your toilet has a leak, start by inspecting the flapper, which controls the water flow from the tank to the bowl. If the flapper is worn, damaged, or not properly sealing, it can cause water to leak into the bowl. Additionally, check the water level in the tank; if it is above the overflow tube, it may lead to water continuously running into the bowl.

rejoining water lines

Detecting Water Supply Issues

Another factor that can cause a running toilet is problems with the water supply. The fill valve is responsible for refilling the tank after the toilet is flushed. If the fill valve is damaged or leaking, it can cause the toilet to keep running. A slow, intermittent leak could be responsible for the toilet running randomly.

Moreover, the amount of water in the tank can affect the toilet’s functioning. If there’s too little or too much water in the tank, it can lead to issues like continuously running water or a toilet that flushes randomly.

To identify water supply issues, start by examining the fill valve for any visible damage or leaks. If you find a problem, replacing or adjusting the fill valve can help fix the toilet. Additionally, ensure that the water level in the tank is appropriate, typically about one inch below the overflow tube.

By understanding the signs of a running toilet and knowing how to identify underlying issues, you can confidently address these problems and prevent future occurrences. Regular maintenance and checks can keep your toilet functioning efficiently, saving both water and money in the long run.

Troubleshooting a Running Toilet

Testing for Leaks

To troubleshoot a running toilet, it is essential to determine if the toilet is leaking. Start by turning off the water supply at the wall by twisting the angle valve clockwise. Wait for a minimum of 2 hours, then mark the water level in the toilet tank using a pencil. If the water level drops below the pencil mark, this indicates a leak in the tank, potentially caused by a faulty flapper or flush valve 1.

In addition, you can pour a small amount of vinegar into the overflow tube in the toilet tank. If the vinegar starts to flow into the toilet bowl without flushing, this may indicate a leaky or damaged refill tube.

Examining the Flapper Chain

Another possible cause of an intermittently running toilet is an improperly installed or adjusted flapper chain. The flapper chain connects the toilet handle to the flapper, allowing the flapper to lift and close as needed when the toilet is flushed. If the chain is too long or too short, it can hinder the flapper’s ability to completely seal the hole, resulting in a randomly running toilet 2.

To check the flapper chain, remove the toilet tank lid and inspect the chain’s length and attachment. Ensure that the chain is neither too loose nor too tight and properly connected to both the handle and the flapper. Adjust the length of the chain if necessary to achieve a smooth and efficient operation.

Checking Water Level and Float

An issue with the water level in the toilet tank or a malfunctioning float valve can also cause an intermittently running toilet. To check the water level, remove the toilet tank lid, and observe if the water is reaching the designated fill line. If the water level is too high or too low, adjust the float valve accordingly. This can typically be done by bending the float arm or turning an adjustment screw on the fill valve 3.

By following these troubleshooting steps for a running toilet, it is possible to identify any issues that may be causing the problem, such as leaks, improper flapper chain installation, or incorrect water level and float adjustments. Armed with this information, the necessary repairs or adjustments can be made to ensure a properly functioning toilet. 4

How To Replace A Toilet Fill Valve In 15 Minutes

Fixing a Running Toilet

Replacing Worn-Out Parts

One of the key steps to fixing a running toilet is identifying and replacing worn-out parts, such as the flapper or flapper seat. A common cause for a running toilet is an improperly installed flapper chain, which can prevent the flapper from sealing the hole completely1. If you’re experiencing this issue, first turn off the shutoff valve, then take a trip to your local hardware store to purchase the necessary replacement parts. Armed with a screwdriver and wire cutters, you can remove the old flapper and flapper seat and replace them with the new ones. Be sure to fasten the bolts and secure the lock nut, ensuring that the flapper chain is adjusted to the correct length.

Cleaning with Vinegar Solution

Sometimes, the issue with a running toilet can be resolved by cleaning build-up and deposits from crucial parts using a vinegar solution. This can help clear any obstructions and improve the functioning of the toilet. To do this, first turn off the shutoff valve before disassembling the necessary components, such as the fill valve or flapper seat. Soak these parts in a mixture of equal parts water and white vinegar for 30 minutes to an hour, allowing the solution to break down and dissolve deposits. Afterward, gently scrub the parts with a soft brush or cloth, then reassemble your toilet and restore the water supply.

Addressing Overflow Tube and Water Level Issues

Finally, you may need to address any problems with the overflow tube and water level in your running toilet. An improper water level can lead to the toilet running intermittently2. To tackle this issue, first, turn off the shutoff valve and then remove the tank lid. Locate the fill tube, a small flexible tube that runs from the fill valve to the toilet overflow tube3. Check if it’s correctly attached and functioning properly. If necessary, adjust or replace the overflow tube. Furthermore, ensure that the water level in the tank is neither too high nor too low, as this will affect the efficiency of your toilet.

By taking these straightforward steps to replace worn-out parts, clean with a vinegar solution, and address overflow tube and water level issues, you can confidently stop your running toilet and improve its overall performance.

When to Call a Professional

Identifying a Malfunctioning Toilet

A malfunctioning toilet can be quite troublesome, especially if it runs intermittently. In such cases, it’s essential to address the issue promptly to avoid water wastage and increased utility bills. If you have tried a few quick fixes and still face the same problem, consider calling a professional plumber to assess the situation and resolve it.

Experienced plumbers are well-equipped to identify the root cause of a running toilet, which could include issues with the flapper, the fill valve, or even the flush valve. They can diagnose the problem and suggest the most appropriate solution to rectify it. Remember, prolonged neglect of a running toilet may lead to more significant problems that can be both inconvenient and costly.

Considering a Replacement Fill Valve

One of the most common reasons for a running toilet is a malfunctioning fill valve. The fill valve is responsible for regulating the amount of water that enters the toilet tank after each flush. If it fails to function properly, the water may continuously flow into the tank, causing the toilet to run intermittently.

A professional plumber can assess whether the fill valve needs to be adjusted, repaired, or replaced altogether. In some cases, adjusting the valve may be sufficient to fix the issue. However, if the valve is damaged or outdated, a replacement fill valve may be the best long-term solution. A plumber can help you in selecting the right fill valve for your toilet and ensure a seamless installation process.

By calling in a professional plumber to handle a malfunctioning toilet, you can save yourself time, effort, and potential frustration, while also ensuring that the issue is completely resolved. Don’t hesitate to seek their expertise when faced with persistent toilet problems, as they possess the necessary skills and knowledge to address the situation effectively and efficiently.


Preventing Future Toilet Issues

Regular Cleaning and Maintenance

Regular cleaning and maintenance are essential to keeping your toilet running smoothly and avoiding intermittent issues. By frequently cleaning the toilet bowl, internal components, and surrounding area, you can prevent buildup and debris that could contribute to a poorly functioning toilet. Ensure that any worn-out parts are replaced promptly, and keep external components like the handle and hinge points in good condition by cleaning them thoroughly.

It’s essential to check the toilet’s flush and fill valves and adjust them as needed. A properly serviced toilet will not only have a longer lifespan but also improve its overall functionality. Keep in mind that constant vigilance and preventative measures can save you time, effort, and money in the long run.

Choosing High-Quality Toilet Components

When it comes to choosing toilet components, selecting high-quality parts can significantly reduce the chances of future toilet issues. Investing in durable and reliable components for key elements like the fill valve and the flush valve will result in fewer problems over time.

Try to source toilet components from reputable manufacturers who emphasize quality and durability. Remember, investing in high-quality parts in the initial installation or during replacements can prevent the need for constant repairs in the future by prolonging the life of the toilet system.

In conclusion, preventing future toilet issues relies on a combination of regular cleaning and maintenance, as well as choosing high-quality toilet components. By staying diligent and taking these steps, you can ensure that your toilet remains functional and problem-free for years to come.


In closing, addressing the issue of a toilet running intermittently is not just beneficial for the smooth functioning of the plumbing system, but it also helps in avoiding potential water damage and lowering water bills. A proactive approach towards fixing this common problem ensures a hassle-free experience for homeowners and tenants alike.

With some basic plumbing knowledge, one can diagnose and resolve most toilet running issues without the need for professional intervention. This skill comes in handy for those looking to save on plumbing costs and take control of maintaining their own living spaces. Nonetheless, when dealing with more complex problems or facing difficulty in identifying the root causes, seeking expert advice is always recommended.

Ultimately, being attentive to the plumbing system in one’s home and addressing problems early on can lead to a more efficient household operation and reduced water expenses. Regular maintenance, timely repairs, and an understanding of toilet components go a long way in staying on top of potential issues and safeguarding the overall function and hygiene of the living space.

Frequently Asked Questions

What causes a toilet to run intermittently?

There are several possible causes for a toilet to run intermittently. Common issues include an improperly installed flapper chain, a slow leak from the tank into the bowl, or a damaged fill valve. These problems can cause water to trickle into the bowl, resulting in the toilet running without being flushed 1.

How can I fix a toilet that keeps running after flushing?

Fixing a toilet that keeps running after flushing can be accomplished by addressing the underlying issue. Check the flapper chain to ensure it is properly installed and not damaged. If the problem persists, inspect the fill valve or float mechanism and replace it if necessary 2.

How do you stop water from trickling into the toilet bowl?

Stopping water from trickling into the bowl involves identifying the root cause – typically a leaky flapper or a damaged fill valve. Once you’ve located the problem, you can replace the damaged part or adjust the flapper chain to ensure it seals the hole properly 3.

Does a phantom flush increase the water bill?

Yes, a phantom flush can increase the water bill. Because it involves a slow leak from the tank into the bowl, it leads to water waste, which can significantly increase water consumption and, in turn, raise your water bill over time 4.

Can I repair a phantom flush without a plumber?

It is possible to repair a phantom flush without a plumber. By diagnosing the issue and determining the cause, you can replace or adjust the damaged parts yourself. However, it’s always a good idea to consult a professional if you’re unsure or unable to solve the issue on your own 5.

How do I fix a running toilet without a ball float?

If your toilet lacks a ball float mechanism, it likely has a different type of float system, such as a float cup. Float cups can also be adjusted or replaced to fix a running toilet. Consult the manufacturer’s instructions for your specific make and model or seek professional assistance if needed 6.


  1. 2 3
  2. 2 3
  3. 2 3
  4. 2
author avatar
Anthony Barnes
Anthony Barnes is the founder of Water Heater Hub and a second-generation plumber by profession. Before developing Water Heater Hub, Anthony Barnes was a full-time plumber, and he has undertaken a wide variety of projects over the decades. As a second-generation plumber, it was easy for Anthony to get used to the technicalities of all from a tender age


On Key

Related Posts

Is Drano Bad for Pipes? The Truth Revealed

Note: This post may contain affiliate links. This means that at no cost to you, we may receive a small commission for made purchases. When it comes to dealing with clogged drains, many homeowners turn